Great American Coin Company Reviews: Legit or Not? Find Out Here

7.9/10 (Expert Score)
Product is rated as #15 in category Dealers
7.9Expert Score
Great American Coin Co. Review

With over a thousand reviews online, this coin dealer stands out as one of the most popular options among collectors and numismatists.

Trust
8
Fees
8
Customer Service
8
Reputation
7.5
Pros
  • Large Product Selection
  • IRA-Eligible Products
  • Experienced Team
Cons
  • Limited Online Presence

Great American Coin Company: Unique Highlights Overview

The Great American Coin Company, established in 2006 by Gary Dyner in Los Angeles, California, is a family-owned enterprise renowned for its extensive selection of numismatic products and commitment to customer satisfaction. 

Find the Best Gold IRA Company of Your State

AL AK AZ AR CA CO CT DE FL GA HI ID IL IN IA KS KY LA ME MD MA MI MN MS MO MT NE NV NH NJ NM NY NC ND OH OK OR PA RI SC SD TN TX UT VT VA WA WV WI WY DC

  • Diverse Product Range: The company offers a comprehensive array of items, including U.S. and international coins, bullion (gold, silver, platinum), and collectible banknotes. This extensive selection caters to both seasoned collectors and new enthusiasts.
  • Authenticity and Quality Assurance: As a member of the American Numismatic Association and an authorized reseller of NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Corporation) and PMG (Paper Money Guaranty) products, the company ensures that all items meet stringent standards of authenticity and quality.
  • Customer-Centric Approach: The Great American Coin Company emphasizes an integrity-based approach to transactions, striving to exceed customer expectations through knowledgeable and dependable service.
  • Educational Resources: The company provides informative content on coin collecting, including blogs and FAQs, to assist both novice and experienced collectors in making informed decisions.
  • Secure and Efficient Transactions: With a user-friendly website and secure checkout process, customers can browse and purchase products with confidence. The company also offers prompt shipping and various payment options to enhance the buying experience.

These attributes distinguish the Great American Coin Company as a reputable and customer-focused entity in the numismatic community.

Who are the People Behind Great American Coin Company?

The Great American Coin Company is a family-owned business based in Los Angeles, California. It was founded in 2006 by Gary Dyner, who brought his passion for gold, silver, and numismatic coin collecting to the enterprise. citeturn0search21

In 2010, Stephen Dyner joined the company, contributing his expertise in business management and marketing. Together, they have focused on providing customers with an integrity-based approach to purchasing precious metals and collectible coins and currency. citeturn0search21

Does Great American Coin Company Offer IRA Services?

The Great American Coin Company (GACC) is renowned for its range of coins, bullion, and collectible items. However, its focus does not extend directly to providing Individual Retirement Account (IRA) services. Below is a detailed explanation of what GACC offers and how individuals can integrate precious metals into an IRA through alternative avenues.

Great American Coin Company’s Core Offerings

GACC specializes in the sale of precious metals, coins, and paper currency. Their offerings include:

  • Gold and Silver Bullion: Popular with collectors and investors.
  • Rare Coins: Numismatic items valued for their historical and collectible significance.
  • Novelty and Specialty Items: Such as uncirculated rolls and commemorative sets.

Despite this comprehensive catalog, GACC does not explicitly advertise or support IRA-related services, such as setting up self-directed IRAs or facilitating IRS-compliant storage of metals.

What Are Precious Metals IRAs?

Precious Metals IRAs are self-directed IRAs that allow investors to include physical gold, silver, platinum, and palladium in their retirement accounts. These IRAs are a popular option for diversifying retirement portfolios.

  • IRS-Compliant Custodians: A specialized custodian manages the account and ensures compliance with IRS regulations.
  • Approved Precious Metals: Only certain bullion and coins meet IRS standards for inclusion in IRAs, including specific purity levels (e.g., 99.5% purity for gold).
  • Secure Storage: Metals must be stored in an IRS-approved depository, not in personal possession.

How to Incorporate GACC Products into an IRA

Although GACC does not directly offer IRA services, their products may be eligible for IRA inclusion if they meet the necessary standards. To use GACC products for an IRA:

  1. Verify IRA Eligibility of Metals:
    • Confirm that the gold, silver, or other bullion purchased meets IRS purity requirements.
    • Check if GACC explicitly lists which products are IRA-approved.
  2. Work with a Self-Directed IRA Custodian:
    • Choose a custodian specializing in Precious Metals IRAs to handle account setup and compliance.
    • Share product details from GACC with the custodian to ensure compatibility.
  3. Arrange for Depository Storage:
    • Purchase eligible metals from GACC and have them shipped directly to an IRS-approved depository.
    • Avoid taking personal possession to maintain compliance.

Recommendations for IRA Investors

If your goal is to integrate precious metals into your retirement portfolio, consider the following:

  • Consult with Experts: Financial advisors or custodians specializing in self-directed IRAs can guide the process and recommend appropriate metals.
  • Compare Vendors: Look for dealers who explicitly advertise IRA-compliant products to streamline the process.
  • Research Storage Options: Understand the costs and logistics of depository storage.

While the Great American Coin Company does not provide dedicated IRA services, their products could potentially be used in a Precious Metals IRA if they meet IRS standards. Investors seeking to include GACC products in their IRA should work with a qualified self-directed IRA custodian to ensure proper handling and compliance. 

What Products Can You Purchase at Great American Coin Company?

The Great American Coin Company (GACC) offers a wide range of products catering to collectors, investors, and numismatics enthusiasts. Below is a detailed breakdown of the categories and items you can purchase.

U.S. Coins

GACC specializes in a variety of United States coins, appealing to collectors interested in the nation’s numismatic history.

  • Circulated and Uncirculated Coins: Includes coins from various eras in both circulated and mint condition.
  • Historic Coins: Such as Barber dimes, Indian Head pennies, and Buffalo nickels.
  • Silver Dollars: Iconic coins like the Morgan and Peace Silver Dollars, valued for their historical significance and silver content.
  • Modern Collectibles: Commemorative coins and limited editions from the U.S. Mint.
  • Uncirculated Rolls: Bank-wrapped or sealed rolls of U.S. coins for collectors seeking pristine examples.

Precious Metals Bullion

Precious metals are a major focus of GACC, attracting both investors and collectors.

  • Gold Bullion:
    • Gold bars of varying weights.
    • Gold rounds and coins, including popular options like the American Gold Eagle and Gold Buffalo.
  • Silver Bullion:
    • Silver bars in sizes ranging from 1 oz to 100 oz.
    • Silver coins and rounds, including iconic designs like the American Silver Eagle.
  • Platinum and Palladium: Occasionally available bars and coins for diversification in precious metals investments.

World Coins

GACC offers an array of international coins, expanding its appeal to global collectors.

  • Historic World Coins: Rare and collectible coins from regions like Europe, Asia, and the Middle East.
  • Modern Bullion Coins: Such as Canadian Maple Leafs, South African Krugerrands, and Australian Kangaroos.

Collectible Paper Currency

The company features a collection of rare and collectible banknotes from both the U.S. and other countries.

  • U.S. Paper Money: Including silver certificates, Federal Reserve notes, and historically significant series.
  • World Currency: Unique and rare banknotes from various nations.

Specialty and Novelty Items

In addition to traditional coins and bullion, GACC offers unique and creative products for collectors.

  • Novelty Coins and Rounds: Fun designs and themes that appeal to casual collectors or for gifting purposes.
  • Commemorative Sets: Themed coin sets for special occasions, anniversaries, or historical events.
  • Custom Products: Occasionally, GACC provides customized coin-related products, such as display sets or engraved items.

Educational and Collecting Accessories

To enhance the collecting experience, GACC also offers tools and resources.

  • Coin Holders and Storage Supplies: Products to protect and organize collections.
  • Books and Guides: Educational materials about coin collecting and numismatics.

Rare and Limited-Edition Pieces

For seasoned collectors, GACC provides opportunities to acquire rare and hard-to-find coins and currency.

  • Graded Coins: Coins professionally graded by certification bodies like NGC or PCGS.
  • Scarce Varieties: Unique mints, errors, and varieties that add historical and monetary value.

Themed and Seasonal Offerings

Occasionally, GACC introduces special themed collections or seasonal promotions that align with holidays or events.

The Great American Coin Company offers an expansive product range, making it a destination for both collectors and investors. Their catalog spans U.S. and world coins, bullion in various metals, collectible currency, and novelty items. 

Great American Coin Company Fees and Pricing:

The Great American Coin Company (GACC) offers a diverse range of numismatic products and precious metals, with pricing influenced by factors such as market fluctuations, product type, and payment methods. Here’s a detailed overview of their fees and pricing structure:

Product Pricing

  • Market-Linked Prices: Prices for bullion items, including gold and silver coins and bars, are closely tied to current market spot prices. These prices can change rapidly due to market volatility. GACC provides live pricing updates to reflect these fluctuations.
  • Collectible Items: The pricing of rare coins, banknotes, and other collectibles is determined by factors such as rarity, condition, and demand. These items may carry premiums over their intrinsic metal value due to their numismatic significance.

Payment Methods and Associated Fees

  • Accepted Payments: GACC accepts various payment methods, including Visa, American Express, MasterCard, PayPal, and wire transfers.
  • Wire Transfer Fees: For payments made via wire transfer, there is a $40 fee.
  • PayPal Fees: Payments received through PayPal may incur additional fees charged to the customer. It’s advisable to review PayPal’s fee structure or consult with GACC for specific details.

Shipping and Handling Charges

  • Domestic Shipping: Shipping fees are calculated based on the delivery method chosen during checkout. GACC offers various shipping options, each with its own cost structure.
  • International Shipping: International orders may incur higher shipping fees, and customers are responsible for any additional costs such as customs duties or taxes. GACC recommends that international buyers choose PayPal at checkout and select the Express Mail International option for shipping.

Returns and Restocking Fees

  • Return Policy: If there is an issue with any shipment, including damaged or defective merchandise, missing items, or incorrect orders, GACC must be notified within 7 business days of receipt. Returns should be securely wrapped and insured.
  • Restocking Fees: For products returned that fall outside the stated return policy, GACC may, at its discretion, institute a restocking fee ranging from 10% to 30%.

Selling to GACC

  • Buyback Program: GACC offers a straightforward buyback process for certain items, such as specific currencies and silver products. Sellers are responsible for shipping costs and ensuring safe delivery. Upon successful inspection, payment is processed within 7 business days.
  • Payment Options for Sellers: Payments can be made via PayPal (with customer-incurred fees), check (free), or wire transfer (with a $40 fee). For payments over $1,000, additional information, including a social security number or Business EIN, may be required.

Additional Considerations

  • Price Competitiveness: While GACC strives to offer competitive pricing, it’s advisable for customers to compare prices with other dealers to ensure the best value. Some reviews suggest that pricing may not always be the most competitive in the market.
  • Authenticity Assurance: GACC is an authorized dealer for PCGS and NGC, ensuring that products meet strict standards of authenticity and quality.

What Do Great American Coin Company Reviews Say?

The Great American Coin Company (GACC) has received various ratings across multiple platforms. Here’s a detailed overview:

Trustpilot

  • Rating: 3.3 out of 5 stars
  • Number of Reviews: 1,814
  • Summary: This rating indicates a mix of positive and negative customer experiences. Common praises include product quality and customer service, while criticisms often pertain to pricing and shipping times. 

Yelp

  • Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
  • Summary: Yelp reviews highlight GACC’s wide product range and professional service. Some customers have noted issues related to pricing and shipping, but overall, the feedback is predominantly positive. 

eBay

  • Seller Status: Top Rated Seller
  • Feedback: 4,445 positive feedbacks in the last 12 months
  • Summary: GACC maintains a strong presence on eBay, consistently delivering outstanding customer service and maintaining high satisfaction levels among buyers. 

GACC generally holds favorable ratings across these platforms, reflecting a commitment to quality products and customer service. However, as with any purchase, it’s advisable to review recent customer feedback and compare options to ensure they meet your specific needs.

Examples of Great American Coin Company Reviews:

It was nice for them to review GACC again. GACC was recognized as the best, known for being fast, efficient, and professional. As he had said before, other companies could take a leaf out of their book. His experience had been the same every time, from order to delivery. The airlines made mistakes from time to time. His previous package had been in delivery for five days. It had arrived in NZ the day before after five days, at 15:28, in Auckland. He informed them that it was not America, and that LA had shipped immediately on the 22nd. 

The currency had arrived as promised, and it was entirely authentic, accompanied by a certificate. The website had been user-friendly, and their prices had been competitive yet fair. All in all, they were a satisfied customer. They gave the GACC an A+- 5 stars – thumbs up! They were his go-to guys.

They had ordered a few times from Great American Coin Company, and their service was absolutely amazing. They lived in Canada and within days they received their order. They provided a tracking number and could watch where the order was at. They expressed gratitude for the excellent service received.

They had dealt with this company three times, purchasing Vietnamese dong, Iraqi dinar, and Zimbabwean Zim. They had reasonable prices and great customer service. It had been very easy for them to order, and they had even sent at least 10 more customers recently. He recommended that company as a five-star company anytime.

Why aren’t There Many Great American Coin Company Complaints?

The Great American Coin Company (GACC) has a relatively low number of complaints for several reasons, which reflect their business practices, reputation, and customer-focused approach. Here’s a detailed exploration of why this is the case:

Emphasis on Quality and Authenticity

  • High-Quality Products: GACC offers products that are often certified by reputable third-party graders like the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) or the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS). This minimizes disputes over authenticity or condition.
  • Diverse Inventory: Their wide selection of coins, bullion, and collectibles caters to varied customer interests, reducing the likelihood of dissatisfaction.

Transparency in Transactions

  • Clear Pricing: GACC provides transparent pricing, especially for precious metals tied to market spot prices. This helps customers make informed decisions and avoids pricing disputes.
  • Detailed Product Descriptions: The company ensures product descriptions are accurate and comprehensive, which minimizes misunderstandings or false expectations.

Customer-Centric Approach

  • Responsive Customer Service: GACC emphasizes a customer-first philosophy, addressing issues promptly and effectively.
  • Generous Return Policy: Their return policy allows customers to resolve issues with damaged or incorrect products, reducing complaints.
  • Educational Support: By offering blogs, FAQs, and guides, GACC empowers customers to make informed purchases, reducing errors and complaints.

Positive Reputation and Credibility

  • Established Trust: Operating since 2006, GACC has built a reputation for integrity and reliability, fostering trust among customers.
  • Accreditations and Affiliations: Membership in the American Numismatic Association and their status as an authorized dealer for NGC and PMG further reassure customers of their credibility.

Efficient Logistics

  • Timely Shipping: GACC is noted for efficient shipping practices, ensuring customers receive their orders promptly. While delays can happen, they appear to be rare and well-managed.
  • Secure Packaging: Products are shipped securely to prevent damage, reducing the likelihood of complaints about the condition of items upon arrival.

Proactive Complaint Management

  • Complaint Resolution: GACC actively resolves issues brought to their attention, preventing escalations and public complaints.
  • Open Communication Channels: Their responsive customer service helps resolve misunderstandings or dissatisfaction directly with customers, reducing the need for public complaints.

Smaller Business Scale

  • Controlled Operations: As a family-owned business, GACC operates on a scale that allows them to focus on individual customer satisfaction. This direct attention helps avoid common pitfalls faced by larger corporations.

Loyal Customer Base

  • Repeat Customers: GACC’s focus on quality and service fosters a loyal customer base less likely to complain and more likely to resolve issues amicably.
  • Positive Reviews: Satisfied customers often leave glowing reviews, which can overshadow isolated negative experiences.

The low volume of complaints about the Great American Coin Company can be attributed to their commitment to product quality, transparency, customer service, and efficient operations. While no business is immune to criticism, GACC’s proactive measures and reputation help maintain a largely positive relationship with their customer base.

Are There Any Great American Coin Company Lawsuits?

No.

We didn’t find any lawsuits involving this company.

Can You Trust the Great American Coin Company? Is Great American Coin Company Legit?

Yes.

They are a legit company with thousands of reviews online.

Whenever you’re curious about a gold dealer, follow these tips:

Tip #1: Check Their Regulatory Compliance and Accreditation

Check for proper licensing and registration with relevant financial regulatory bodies such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) or Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA).

Verify the company’s accreditation with industry organizations like the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) or the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC).

It will help you check how credible they are.

Tip #2: Look into The Company’s Background

  1. Research the company’s history, including years in business and any name changes.
  2. Examine the Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating and accreditation status.
  3. Review customer feedback on reputable third-party review sites like Trustpilot or Consumer Affairs.

Tip #3: Does the Company Offer Good Resources?

  1. Assess the clarity of information provided about fees, storage options, and buyback policies.
  2. Evaluate the quality and depth of educational resources offered to investors.
  3. Verify that the company provides clear information about IRS regulations regarding precious metals IRAs.

Tip #4: What are Their Product Offerings and Pricing?

  1. Ensure the company offers IRS-approved precious metals for IRA investments.
  2. Compare pricing with other reputable dealers to ensure competitiveness.
  3. Be wary of companies pushing numismatic or collectible coins over bullion for IRA investments.

Tip #5: Confirm the Storage and Custodian Partnerships

Verify that the company works with IRS-approved custodians and secure storage facilities. According to IRS’ regulations, you cannot store your gold IRA’s precious metals at your home.

You’ll need a certified third-party storage provider.

Check the company’s storage and custodian partner to ensure you’re working with a reliable firm. Moreover, ensure they offer segregated storage options for your precious metals.

Segregated storage means your owned precious metals products will be stored separately from other investors’ possessions. Similarly, non-segregated storage means your products will be stored along with others.

Keep in mind that storage providers charge extra for segregated storage.

Some popular custodians include Equity Trust and Goldstar Trust.

Red Flags to Watch For in Gold IRA Companies

  1. Promises of guaranteed returns or claims of “secret” investment strategies.
  2. Pressure to act immediately or make large investments without proper consideration.
  3. Lack of physical address or unclear company ownership structure.
  4. Unwillingness to provide detailed information about fees or policies in writing.

By thoroughly evaluating these aspects, investors can make an informed decision about the legitimacy and reliability of a gold IRA company. It’s crucial to conduct due diligence and, if necessary, consult with a financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Great American Coin Company Review Summary:

Overall, Great American Coin Co. is a legit company with a lot to offer.

Have you had any experience dealing with this firm?

Let us know in the comments.

Great American Coin Company Reviews: Legit or Not? Find Out Here
Great American Coin Company Reviews: Legit or Not? Find Out Here

David
We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Gold IRA Directory
Logo